Best Crib Mattress 2020 – Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

Last Updated on

If you are interested and buying the best crib mattress available for your child, there are a lot of things that you need to know before you actually make a purchase.

best baby mattress

First and foremost, you want a mattress that is going to be capable of providing your baby with a comfortable place to sleep. However, there is nothing more important than the safety of your child. Obviously, you wouldn’t want to choose a crib mattress that has any type of potential safety issues so it is imperative that you rule any products out that might fall into that category before you ever seriously consider purchasing one of them.

Moreover, you probably have to choose a crib mattress that fits your individual needs. Those needs will change depending on how many children you have, the individual ages of those children and whether or not there are any specific concerns that might be unique to them. In addition, you obviously want to get the most bang for your buck so you don’t want to spend a lot of money on something that isn’t going to provide a decent return on your investment. With that being said, you may not want to purchase the most economical mattress out there but if you do, you should be able to get one at an economical price that still provides plenty of safety and comfort. Simply put, you shouldn’t have to settle for something that is of lesser quality because you are trying to save money when you make your purchase.

Below are five different crib mattresses that are reviewed in detail. You can use this as a guide when choosing your own mattress for your child. It helps you cut through all of the different information you might find online and narrow down your choices to one or two products that you want to see firsthand.The first thing you will find in this guide is the name of the mattress, followed by its features. There is also information related to both the advantages and disadvantages of owning each mattress. At the end of the guide, you can find information about the best choice overall, as well as the best choice if you are on a serious budget.

Crib Mattress Comparison

ItemNameRatingPrice 
Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed
Newton Baby Crib Mattress
4.5 out of 5 stars
$$$
Check Price
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress
4 out of 5 stars
$
Check Price
Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress
Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress
4 out of 5 stars
$$
Check Price
Sealy Nature Couture Cotton Bliss 2-Stage Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress
Sealy Nature Couture Crib Mattress
4 out of 5 stars
$$
Check Price
My First Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress Premium Memory Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress Combination
My First Crib Mattress
4 out of 5 stars
$$
Check Price

Crib Mattress Reviews

Newton Baby Crib Mattress

baby crib mattress

Like most mattresses that are used for small children, this one is hypoallergenic. It is also both washable and breathable. All of these things are positive notes about the mattress. You want to choose one that is hypoallergenic so you don’t have to worry as much about allergens getting into the mattress and then causing other upper respiratory infections or other issues related to allergies as a direct result of having your child sleep on the mattress. You obviously want one that is washable, as any parent knows that children can sometimes have a lot of accidents when sleeping. In addition, you need to have a mattress that is breathable, especially for young children.

Most parents think that this means that the mattress does not get stale because the fabric is breathable, but it really means that even if your child turns over on his or her stomach, the child will still be able to breathe even with his face planted firmly in the mattress. This is something that makes many parents feel more at ease when leaving their children alone to sleep in their crib. Other people like this mattress because it prevents the growth of bacteria and it also helps your child better regulate their temperature while sleeping on it. It is actually made from air and food grade polymer that is then wrapped up in a breathable fabric. Therefore, it is completely recyclable. As if that were not enough, it is important to point out that every single product on this list has definite advantages. The thing that makes this one stand out is that it has many of the same advantages that the other products on the list have, only they are combined together in a single product. This makes this particular mattress worth taking a second and even a third look at as you make your decision.

PROS
  • The mattress is compact.
  • It is easy to clean.
  • There are no worries if the child rolls over.
CONS
  • This mattress has a tendency to sag somewhat in the middle with continued use.

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

safety first mattress

Like the other mattress, this one is also hypoallergenic, a major plus for any parent that is considering purchasing a new mattress for their child. It is also a firm mattress that provides good support without being uncomfortable. Its firmness is something that many individuals are seeking, especially for those who have younger children who could not safely sleep on a softer and more pliable mattress. It is an extremely durable product but despite its durability and firmness, it is surprisingly lightweight.

It is made to be completely free of lead or phthalates and it comes with a removable vinyl cover that can easily be wiped off and then reinstalled. Therefore, this is a mattress that is not only safe but also comfortable. Just as important, it is easy to maintain so you won’t have to worry about being forced to throw it out even if your child gets a nasty virus and has several accidents on it. This is easily one of the most popular mattresses among individuals who have children. Even if you did not have this type of guide to look through, you would easily be able to see that when so many people are purchasing a certain product, there has to be a reason for it somewhere. That alone stands as a testament to both the durability and the quality of this mattress, as individuals would not continue to purchase it in large numbers if it were not capable of meeting their needs.

PROS
  • It can stand up to a great deal of punishment without showing any signs of wear.
  • The mattress is comfortable.
  • It is built to last, with children in mind.
CONS
  • Customer support could be better when it comes to answering questions.

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress

soybean foam crib

One of the things that this mattress has going for it right away is the fact that it is made by Sealy, a company that has traditionally been known as one of the most quality-driven mattress manufacturers in existence. As far as this particular product goes, it is an extra firm and extremely lightweight mattress that has been certified to be safe for children. It is actually designed to prevent allergens from forming within the mattress, thereby either reducing or even preventing allergies in the children that sleep on it.

This makes it a great choice for anyone who has a child that is already suffering from a number of allergies because many of those allergens can be dramatically reduced or eliminated, thereby reducing the symptoms that the child might experience. In addition, the mattress has a cover that is both waterproof and stain resistant. It can easily be removed, cleaned and then put back on. Many people are actually impressed enough with the fact that the mattress is made by Sealy to immediately consider it for purchase, even before they know what the exact benefits of owning it really are. As is the case with most products made by the company, this one does not disappoint. The truth is, it is a high-quality product that is similar to what one might expect from a company of this stature.

PROS
  • There is very little sagging involved, even when used extensively.
  • Wipe the cover clean and you’re done, with nothing more to worry about.
  • The mattress is highly durable.
CONS
  • There may be a slight chemical smell upon unwrapping the new mattress, which is common.

Sealy Nature Couture Cotton Bliss Crib Mattress

sealy nature crib mattress

Not only is this mattress made by Sealy, but it also features something that very few children’s mattresses are capable of producing. It is literally a mattress that can be used for either infants or toddlers, depending on which side of the mattress you choose to have facing upward. This makes it a great purchase for anyone that wants to purchase a single product and use it throughout their child’s development. It also works especially well if you have more than one child in the family and you are trying to cut down on costs associated with buying one mattress after another.

In addition, this one is made from organic cotton and it is free from any type of plastic. It also provides good support regardless of the age range of your child. All you have to do is flip it over in order to find the side that corresponds to your child’s age. You want the firm, flat side for infants and you can use the more pliable side for toddlers in order to provide an extra level of comfort. If you are uncomfortable with the idea of purchasing a new mattress every time your child enters a new phase of life, this might very well be the choice for you. There are relatively few products available on the market that offer you this type of versatility. This makes this particular mattress very unique in its ability to allow it to essentially grow with your child. This is a feature that many parents find almost irresistible.

PROS
  • Exceptional quality is provided.
  • This mattress offers the ultimate level of versatility.
  • It features all organic material, with no plastics.
CONS
  • There is some potential sagging in the center, especially after a great deal of use.

My First Crib Mattress

my first crib mattress

Something that makes this particular mattress rather unique is that it is made from memory foam. This is believed to conform to the individual sleeping on it so that it can provide an added level of comfort. Like many of the other mattresses being reviewed here, it has a waterproof cover that can easily be removed and cleaned. The mattress is made from polyurethane foam and is designed to provide an ideal level of comfort.

Perhaps even more importantly, it is also made to be both hypoallergenic and antimicrobial. This can really cut down on the number of nasal allergies and respiratory infections that your child might be going through. The mattress is also mite proof and contains no lead or phthalates. While you might be questioning the use of memory foam as a parent, many individuals who have toddlers find this type of design to be extremely comfortable. You might want to consider it if you have a child that has not been sleeping well or that has been complaining about a mattress that is uncomfortable. Similarly, it is a good idea to consider using a mattress with memory foam if your child seems fussy all the time due to a lack of sleep. While it may not be the best choice for an infant, it can be safely used for toddlers and is often used quite effectively.

PROS
  • It is easy to wash and maintain.
  • This is a firm mattress that is both safe and comfortable.
CONS
  • Like many new mattresses, there is a slight chemical smell that is sometimes noticeable.

Best Crib Mattress

Best Crib Mattress

This is actually a rather close contest, as any of the mattresses in this guide could be considered a suitable purchase for almost any parent. Of course, every individual has their own personal preferences that might sway them to choose a different product in this list, or perhaps even to choose one that isn’t listed here at all, and that is perfectly okay. This guide is only designed to provide some insight into the different products that are available for sale, along with providing some more in-depth details about each product on the list.

When all of the benefits and features are grouped together, the mattress that really stands out is the Newton Crib Mattress, the first one that was listed. The conclusion was reached by looking at the different features available concerning each product, as well as the advantages and disadvantages that are commonly associated with owning each of these products. What makes this particular product the best crib mattress out there? It has a reputation that is second to none, something that any parent would want to know about before purchasing a mattress for their child. In addition, it is easy to maintain because of the washable cover. However, the benefits of owning this particular mattress do not stop there.

baby crib mattress

Many people like the fact that it is completely recyclable, so it doesn’t just have to be thrown away when the child outgrows it and it can no longer be used. That makes it more environmentally friendly but the thing that makes it the best crib mattress out there involves its overall design. The mattress is intended to be safe for children, even when they find themselves in a sleeping position that could sometimes be considered potentially dangerous.

Its breathable design means that children can roll over with a greater degree of safety as opposed to the level of safety available for children who might roll over on their stomach with their face in the mattress. The fact that it prevents bacterial growth is also extremely important. When all of these things are put together, it is easy to see why this is often the choice of parents who want a high quality product that can get the job done.

Best Cheap Crib Mattress

cheap crib mattress

As previously mentioned, you shouldn’t have to settle for inferior quality just because you are on a tight budget. At one time or another, everyone has some concerns that center around their budget. With that being said, you obviously want the best for your child. It simply means that you need to find a product that is capable of doing all of the things you need it to do without costing you an arm and a leg.

Fortunately, you can find a product like that. If this is the situation that you are in, the product that will best suit your needs is unquestionably the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress. What makes this one better than the rest for those who are on a tight budget? The truth is, it could easily be considered by some to be the best crib mattress on the market, at virtually any price range. The fact that it does so at a more economical price point then several other mattresses makes it a good fit for those who are worried about their budget constraints.

crib mattress

As far as performance goes, this is a mattress that is extremely durable and easy to manage. It has a cover that you can take off, clean up and then put back on and even the mattress itself is easy to move around. It is a firm mattress that is comfortable to sleep on and it provides a good amount of support but it doesn’t use items that could be considered potentially harmful to your child like lead or phthalates. When all things are considered, it is easily one of the best products available on the market. It should not be considered as a product that is only available because it is more economical, but instead because of the overall quality of the product itself.

Conclusion

Choosing the best mattress for your child is undoubtedly one of the most important decisions that you will ever make. However, it shouldn’t become a decision that takes up all of your time and stresses you out to the point of near madness as you attempt to find the right product. Many parents do allow themselves to get so caught up in the different choices that are out there that it becomes virtually impossible to choose the best fit for their own needs.

Hopefully, you can use this guide to serve your needs well so that you don’t have to go through a lot of trial and error when choosing a mattress. It gives you five specific products to look at and you know exactly what the advantages and disadvantages of owning each one truly are. That way, you can choose the mattress that works for your family and then move on to the next decision that you have to make, as there is always something around the corner when you have a growing family.

Comments are closed.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Privacy & Cookies Policy